| Year | Recipient | Institution | Title |
| 2003 | Dean Bennett | University of Washington | "Our Goths: Sweden's Myth of National Origin and the Political Rhetoric of Legitimacy, Legality, and Liberty, 1598-1632." |
| 2004 | Glenn Kranking | Tartu University, Estonia |
"Where is My Homeland? Repatriation of Ethnic Swedes in the Early Twentieth Century" |
| 2005 | No Award | |
No Paper was selected for the 2005 Graduate Student Paper Award |
| 2006 | 1st Prize: J. Laurence Hare, Jr. |
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill |
"When the Germans Ran Wild in Denmark: Archeology and Identity During the German Danish Wars, 1848-1865." |
| 2nd Prize: Glenn Kranking |
The Ohio State University | "The Swedish Identity Crisis and Colonial Sweden: 19th Century Neocolonial Expansion and the Swedish Diaspora in the Russian Empire." | |
| 2007 | Daniel Riches | University of Chicago | "Bengt Skytte's Plan for an International Scholarly Community at Tangermünde" |
| 2008 | 1st Prize: Jeff Hartman |
University of Minnesota | "Deforestation and Driftwood: Icelandic Timber Imports in Light of the Archaeology of Dwelling Construction" |
| 2nd Prize: Glenn Kranking |
The Ohio State University | “Jumping Through Windows and the Antichrist: The Absurd Foundations of the Estonian-Swedish Cultural Awakening” | |
| 2009 | 1st Prize: Karl Aspelund, |
Boston University | "Defining National Culture by Stealth and Design: ow a 19th Century Artist and Secret Society Defined 20th Century Icelandic Culture" |
| 2nd Prize: Lori Talcott |
University of St. Thomas | "The Norwegian Bolesølje: A Microcosm of Medieval Aesthetics and Belief" |
For information regarding the award, click here.